Skip to main content

Journey of the Broken Circle (2020, Nintendo Switch) Review


WOE AM I!!!


Also for: Macintosh, Playstation 4, Windows, Windows Apps, Xbox One, Xbox Series


"The soul that sees beauty may sometimes walk alone." - Goethe

In Journey of the Broken Circle you control a circle with a dark pixel for an eye and an open wedge for a mouth. Of course, this makes you look like Pac-Man, the hungry hero of decades past, but the similarities end there. This is a game with a message, and from the first moment to the last of its three-hour journey it never lets us forget it. Your quest is about finding love, and the message is about feeling alone when you're incomplete, and incomplete when you're not alone.

This game, from the Danish-based studio Lovable Hat Cult, has you rolling along a sidescrolling landscape, stuck to the confines of gravity. By default you can only roll left or right and jump. As you fill the broken circle's mouth with different shapes, a.k.a. romantic partners, you add new traversal possibilities. Your first partner, for instance, is a sticky fir cone, who helps you to climb vertical surfaces.


The challenge is mostly about platforming your way forward. Different factors make it tougher, like extreme heat that confuses the circle and inverts the left/right controls. As a platformer it's got decent gameplay, with responsive controls and good enough level design that you don't feel confused about what to do, or where to go. 

The intuitive visuals uses few and clear enough colors to make the way forward apparent. The audio settles for minimalism to help you unwind and take the journey for what it is. The challenges are physics-based, requiring you to figure out how to get past certain obstacles, which is often about finding the right amount of momentum. All-in-all, it should have been a pleasant, albeit pretty nondescript gaming experience.


Unfortunately, this game is ruined by the narrative, that combines symbolism with writing so apparent it can only be interpreted one way. It's told in an almost condescending way, as if it was directed towards little kids, but the subject matter reveals that the audience is really late teenagers or even adults. It is not appealing, nor touching, nor even slightly affecting in any positive manner - it is only annoying and incredibly pandering.

Through constant dialogue, monologue and text messages in the environment, the game never lets you forget: The circle's blank space, a.k.a. its mouth, needs to be filled. The needy circle needs the love of friendship, and friendship in love. It won't settle for anything less. It rolls across the landscape, and sucks up anyone not strong enough to reject its offers to come along.

Some brief acquaintances, like the owl or the fir, have life lessons in store about existentialism or selfishness or whatever, but the circle doesn't pay much attention. So... maybe company wasn't so important after all?


Let's not mince words here: As a protagonist, that circle is a constant pain in the ass, like one of those acquaintances that latches on to you all the time although you have very little in common. It's like controlling the Adoring Fan in The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion. Someone that cannot take "no" for an answer, or understand even the most obvious hints that you wanna be left alone. In the end you have to spell it out, and the prick accuses you of being a prick. 

Yes, this game really has a deplorable protagonist, and even though it's intentional, it becomes a stain on the game's journey towards enlightenment. With such obvious character flaws, both the character arc and end goal is so predictable, you don't really need to take the journey. As a narrative experience, it becomes too formulaic and sometimes downright boring. The only sensation it instilled in me was frustration, because that circle didn't feel relatable.


Another problem, considering this is a game about the struggle against loneliness, is that you're not alone very much. New partners abound, and then leave you a while later, only for a new one to take its place soon thereafter. And the few moments of solitude you have, the circle is being a nuiscance about it, whining and moaning, never allowing the player to actually sympathize with the little twerp. 

In these self-depricating segments it's not enough that the circle starts descending down deep, dark pits; it also starts fantasizing about suicide. And then a boss appears in the shape of a dark snake of Angst, and starts hunting the circle down, who quickly needs to escape. How's that for subtlety?

To help it recuperate from situations like that, the circle later finds solace in the embrace of a piece of moss. Together you roll through some of the game's most infuriating platform challenges, involving a few unreliable catapulting phallic plants, that are so imprecise you might get stuck on the same obstacle for ages. And through it all that circle wallows in self-pity. This is where the anger kicks in.


What should we take literally, and what should we take figuratively? Is Journey of the Broken Circle about finding romance, friendship or a business partner? Does the circle have symbolic casual sex with the moss (the phallic tentacles on this level suggest it), or do they just hug and converse? When considering suicide, is the circle standing on the edge of a building or a cliff? You're free to interpret it any way you like, but who cares and what bloody difference does it make?

It's hard to read between the lines when the game already has lines between the lines. It would have been a better experience by just letting the visuals speak for themselves.


I was surprised to find out that Journey of the Broken Circle won several awards for its narrative design. Last year I played forma.8, a good little 2D Metroidvania with similar art style, also about a circle, that got no such accolades. To me, that game was so much better in communicating loneliness, without using a single word of dialogue. It was all in the visuals. I just remember how small and insignificant I felt as I steered the circle through a hostile world, where even the large celestial bodies looked threatening.

Journey of the Broken Circle is the polar opposite. It proudly claims to be about these things, but fails to establish the emotional connections behind them. And consequently, if it wants me to consider the ramifications of a lonely life, or the problems in finding romantic partners, it does an awful job at it. I cannot indentify with the hero at all, and its adventures mean nothing to me. The platforming may be functional and 100 percent average, but the narrative on top of it bugs me all the way through.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Wing Commander (1990, DOS) Review

ALL YOUR SPACE ARE BELONG TO KILRATHI

Baldur's Gate: Siege of Dragonspear (2016, Windows) Review

NEEDLESS FAN FICTION

Zack Zero (2012, Playstation 3) Review

AVERAGE TO THE MAX

Wolfenstein: The Old Blood (2015, Playstation 4) Review

ONCE MORE INTO THE FRAY

Assassin's Creed: Origins (2017, Playstation 4) Review

MASSIVE TO A FAULT

Assassin's Creed: Syndicate (2015, Playstation 4) Review

THE HIDDEN BLADE OF THE FRANCHISE